Industrial Heat Parity COP

Break-even COP at which electric heat matches a reference gas boiler on energy cost

US

5.271

COP (dimensionless)

2026-05 · monthly

Previous
4.566 2026-04
Change on the previous period
+15.4%
Observations
125

EU27_2020

2.353

COP (dimensionless)

2025-S1 · semi_annual

Previous
2.628 2024-S2
Change on the previous period
-10.5%
Observations
11

GB

3.984

COP (dimensionless)

2026-Q1 · quarterly

Previous
3.942 2025-Q4
Change on the previous period
+1.1%
Observations
109

US

Annual meanRange within the yearInterquartile range
234567COPCOP 4 heat pumpCOP 3COP 2.520162017201820192020202120222023202420252026part2.788gas spike

Series begins January 2016 · 125 observations

The band is the point. The within-year spread is far larger than the year-to-year drift — in 2024 the break-even COP ranged from 3.947 to 6.957. A machine specified on the annual average is specified for a condition that occurs twice a year. The dotted rules mark common heat pump COPs, so a reader finds their own technology on the chart without arithmetic.

Why this matters

The break-even COP is the efficiency an electric heat technology has to beat before it costs less to run than a gas boiler. It is the first screen on any electrification business case, and it is set by the ratio between two fuel prices rather than by the machine — so the same equipment can pass or fail the screen depending on when the question is asked.

What the series shows

Across the ten complete years the annual mean has fallen about 13%, from 5.067 in 2016 to 4.388 in 2025, but that drift is smaller than the swing inside a single year: in 2024 alone the break-even ranged from 3.947 to 6.957. The series low of 2.788, in 2022, was a gas event rather than an electricity one — gas rose 42.5% on 2021 while electricity rose 15.6%, and it reversed the following year when gas fell back 42.5% and electricity moved 3.1%. The larger and steadier pattern is seasonal: pooled across the series the bar sits at 3.544 in February and 5.245 in August, because gas is dearest in the heating season while electricity barely moves. Electric heat is therefore easiest to justify in winter, not hardest.

This period

May 2026 stands at 5.271, above the 2026 year-to-date mean of 4.024 — the normal summer position rather than a change in direction. A machine at COP 4 has had the lower energy-only heat cost in three of the last ten months, and all three were winter months.

Pascal Pemha · release 2026-05 · published September 5, 2026

Seasonal fingerprint

2.03.04.05.06.07.0series meanJan3.544FebMarAprMayJunJul5.245AugSepOctNovDec
February 3.544, August 5.245 — a 48% swing inside the calendar year. The bar is lowest in winter because gas is dearest then while electricity barely moves, so electric heat is easiest to justify in the heating season and hardest in summer. Pooled across all eleven calendar years in the series.

How often would it actually have won?

Share of months, on retail prices. This is a supporting metric of PIDI-E. It is not PIDI-H, which counts hours on wholesale prices by a different method.

Reference COP 2.5

0%25%50%75%100%161820222426

Reference COP 3.0

0%25%50%75%100%161820222426

Reference COP 4.0

0%25%50%75%100%161820222426
Identical y-axis on all three panels, so the comparison is by height. A COP 4 machine was ahead in every month of 2022 and in two months of 2024; a COP 3 machine almost never is.

What this figure cannot support

The electricity price column is reconstructed pending the first EIA refresh, so the break-even COP carries an Estimated evidence tag. The price ratio behind it is measured. The series is US-wide industrial average pricing and does not describe any one site or tariff.

How this index is calculated

Table view and CSV
YearMeanMinMaxP25P75n
20165.0674.0366.2854.5195.54112
20174.3903.5104.9354.0624.79512
20184.3583.1515.1043.9484.90012
20194.6733.3866.0134.0805.37212
20205.3704.0307.1714.4896.25912
20213.6072.1494.4852.7974.15712
20222.7882.4343.1112.5643.04712
20234.8552.9366.0674.1205.66012
20245.3643.9476.9574.2816.11612
20254.3883.4605.2843.6385.14112
2026 (part)4.0242.7435.2713.0384.9185

Download the annual summary as CSV
Download every observation, with its lineage, as CSV

GB

Annual meanRange within the yearInterquartile range
2345678COP2017201820192020202120222023202420252026part

Series begins Q1 1999 · 109 observations

Break-even coefficient of performance for electric industrial heat against a gas boiler, Great Britain. Each point is a calendar year mean of the four quarters; the band shows the spread within the year.

What this figure cannot support

Average prices paid by the manufacturing industry in Great Britain, excluding the Climate Change Levy. Excludes demand charges, carbon pricing, maintenance, capital cost and site-specific contracts. Northern Ireland is not covered. Never combined with the US or EU series.

How this index is calculated

Table view and CSV
YearMeanMinMaxP25P75n
19995.6715.3645.8245.4465.8204
20004.9523.7335.7634.0545.6474
20013.2783.1823.3913.2003.3654
20023.2923.0973.5823.1143.5174
20033.0722.8233.4422.8333.3724
20042.7992.6053.0272.6372.9784
20052.6112.3602.7742.4072.7724
20062.6702.2112.8962.3422.8824
20073.2592.8413.7572.8503.7084
20082.7402.6112.9732.6252.9074
20093.3212.8693.7522.9793.6524
20103.2223.0253.3553.0623.3504
20112.7832.7202.8332.7302.8304
20122.7072.6172.8102.6292.7914
20132.6002.5292.6422.5432.6424
20143.0012.7153.2412.7903.1894
20153.5193.1843.7423.2463.7364
20164.2063.9594.4463.9864.4234
20174.0163.7874.2343.8124.2154
20183.8353.7713.8723.7883.8684
20194.4903.9584.8134.0964.7804
20205.4194.6576.4424.6616.3074
20214.3653.1464.9733.4754.9494
20223.1892.9153.4082.9503.4014
20233.4933.3673.6013.3973.5804
20244.0093.9074.0963.9314.0804
20253.9573.7744.1903.8114.1284
2026 (part)3.9843.9843.9843.9843.9841

Download the annual summary as CSV
Download every observation, with its lineage, as CSV

EU27_2020

Annual meanRange within the yearInterquartile range
11.522.533.54COP2019part2020part20212022202320242025part

Series begins First half of 2019 · 11 observations

Break-even coefficient of performance for electric industrial heat against a gas boiler, EU27. Eurostat publishes these prices twice a year, so each point is a mean of at most two half-years.

What this figure cannot support

An EU27 aggregate of national industrial energy prices, excluding VAT and other recoverable taxes — not the same tax basis as the GB series. Published twice a year, so it moves later and more coarsely. Never combined with the US or GB series.

How this index is calculated

Table view and CSV
YearMeanMinMaxP25P75n
2019 (part)2.3042.3042.3042.3042.3041
2020 (part)2.0272.0272.0272.0272.0271
20212.3412.1522.5302.1522.5302
20222.0011.9282.0741.9282.0742
20232.4102.2762.5432.2762.5432
20242.6552.6282.6822.6282.6822
2025 (part)2.3532.3532.3532.3532.3531

Download the annual summary as CSV
Download every observation, with its lineage, as CSV

What was assumed

ParameterValueEvidenceBasis
boiler efficiency (US)0.85assumedSeasonal net efficiency of an existing industrial gas boiler at part load. User-overridable in any derived tool.
boiler efficiency (EU27_2020)0.85assumedSeasonal net efficiency of an existing industrial gas boiler at part load. The same assumed value the US and GB series use.
boiler efficiency (GB)0.85assumedSeasonal net efficiency of an existing industrial gas boiler at part load. The same assumed value the US series uses, deliberately: the three geographies must differ because their prices differ, not because they assume different boilers.

Source attribution

Source: Eurostat.

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Definition

What it measures
Break-even coefficient of performance for electric industrial heat against a gas boiler
Headline metric
Break-even COP (Estimated)
Supporting metrics
electricity:gas price ratio (Measured); electricity price; gas price
Cadence
Monthly
Panel
Economics & Flexibility
Primary sources
eia-monthly (US); desnz-qep (UK); eurostat (EU)
Licence position
clear — public domain/OGL/EC reuse
Release gate
exact geography-specific series IDs, units, price definitions and vintages stored; no cross-geography blending
Replaces
PIDI-E Electrification Index (name only)

What this does not cover

National/area-average energy prices only. Excludes demand charges, carbon pricing, maintenance, capex and site tariffs. Publish separate US, UK and EU observations; never combine them into one measured value.