Exponent register

Every cost–capacity scaling exponent Pemspring has fitted, including the ones that did not meet the quality bar. This is the working data behind the Cost Index: free to read, free to cite, and published in full rather than in summary.

A scaling exponent describes how cost moves with capacity. An exponent of 1.0 means cost rises in step with size; below 1.0 means larger plant costs proportionally less, which is the economy of scale the six-tenths rule approximates. These are fitted to published cost data by ordinary least squares on log-transformed cost and capacity.

88 fits · 77 meet the quality bar · 14 exponents promoted into 7 published records

Across the 39 qualifying fits on an equipment-cost basis, the median fitted exponent is 0.61, ranging from 0.30 to 1.42. 18 of 39 fall below the six-tenths default.

On an installed-cost basis — 38 qualifying fits — the median is 0.49, ranging from 0.23 to 1.27. That gap is the register's second finding: installed cost scales more gently than equipment cost, which is what makes the installed-cost multiple fall as capacity rises — in 36 of 37 equipment types.

The two bases are quoted separately on purpose. A median taken across both mixes things that scale differently and is not comparable with the six-tenths convention, which is an equipment-cost rule.

The quality bar

A fit meets the quality bar when both hold: the capacity range spans at least 10×, and R² is at least 0.90.

77 of 88 fits meet it. The 11 that do not stay in the table below, marked and with the reason named — 7 fail on capacity range and 4 on R², none on both.

The range condition does the more interesting work. Several failures have an R² of 1.000 across three points spanning a factor of two or three — a perfect fit over a range too narrow to be a scaling law. Publishing those alongside the rule is a better argument for the method than any of the passes.

Showing all 88 fits

Download the register as CSV — free, no subscription, quality-bar rule in the file header.

EquipmentSubtypeCapacity unitBasisExponent nR²PointsRangeQuality barSource
Agitator#1800 RPMhpinstalled0.47810.9348350×MeetsNETL AppB p67high confidence
Agitator#1800 RPMhppurchased0.52120.9443350×MeetsNETL AppB p67high confidence
Air Compressor#R3_FS_L_XX baseline EL0acfmpurchased0.751134×Failscapacity range 4×, below the 10× minimumDOE Compressors ECS NOPR Table IV.25high confidence
Air Compressor#RP_FS_LF_AC baseline EL0acfmpurchased0.57020.9619350×MeetsDOE Compressors ECS NOPR Table IV.23high confidence
Air Compressor#RP_FS_L_AC baseline EL0acfmpurchased0.95220.9994350×MeetsDOE Compressors ECS NOPR Table IV.21high confidence
Air Compressor#RP_VS_LF_AC baseline EL0acfmpurchased0.42660.88014500×FailsR² 0.8801, below the 0.90 minimumDOE Compressors ECS NOPR Table IV.24high confidence
Air Compressor#RP_VS_L_AC baseline EL0acfmpurchased0.95091350×MeetsDOE Compressors ECS NOPR Table IV.22high confidence
Air Cooler#CS tubes, Al finsft2 bare tubeinstalled0.37090.914100×MeetsNETL AppB p59high confidence
Air Cooler#CS tubes, Al finsft2 bare tubepurchased0.48840.94184100×MeetsNETL AppB p59high confidence
Centrifugal Compressor#4 stage, 50 psia dischargeacfminstalled0.45730.92814400×Meetspromoted to centrifugalCompressorNETL AppB p71high confidence
Centrifugal Compressor#4 stage, 50 psia dischargeacfmpurchased0.46260.92334400×Meetspromoted to centrifugalCompressorNETL AppB p71high confidence
Centrifugal Compressor#7-9 stage, 150 psia dischargeacfminstalled0.49440.90683400×MeetsNETL AppB p71high confidence
Centrifugal Compressor#7-9 stage, 150 psia dischargeacfmpurchased0.4990.9063400×MeetsNETL AppB p71high confidence
Centrifugal Compressor#9 stage, 1900 psia dischargeacfminstalled0.35790.8856330×FailsR² 0.8856, below the 0.90 minimumNETL AppB p71high confidence
Centrifugal Compressor#9 stage, 1900 psia dischargeacfmpurchased0.34680.867330×FailsR² 0.8670, below the 0.90 minimumNETL AppB p71high confidence
Centrifugal Fan#CS, 1800 RPM, 6 in H2Ogpm (as printed; see note F2)installed0.5350.91434214.3×MeetsNETL AppB p71medium confidence
Centrifugal Fan#CS, 1800 RPM, 6 in H2Ogpm (as printed; see note F2)purchased0.68240.91634214.3×MeetsNETL AppB p71medium confidence
Centrifugal Pump#CSgpminstalled0.38120.92434100×Meetspromoted to centrifugalPumpNETL AppB p68high confidence
Centrifugal Pump#CSgpmpurchased0.74430.9783310×Meetspromoted to centrifugalPumpNETL AppB p68high confidence
Centrifuge#Batch top-suspended filteringin screen diainstalled0.88240.997432.5×Failscapacity range 2.5×, below the 10× minimumNETL AppB p65high confidence
Centrifuge#Batch top-suspended filteringin screen diapurchased1.2892132.5×Failscapacity range 2.5×, below the 10× minimumNETL AppB p65high confidence
Cooling Tower#15F range/10F approachgpminstalled0.32720.9085440×Meetspromoted to coolingTowerNETL AppB p60high confidence
Cooling Tower#15F range/10F approachgpmpurchased0.86810.9975440×Meetspromoted to coolingTowerNETL AppB p60high confidence
Crusher#Gyratoryhpinstalled1.26930.9998331.2×MeetsNETL AppB p62high confidence
Crusher#Gyratoryhppurchased1.41720.9994331.2×MeetsNETL AppB p62high confidence
Crusher#Ring granulatorhpinstalled0.94070.9975316.7×MeetsNETL AppB p62high confidence
Crusher#Ring granulatorhppurchased0.97270.997316.7×MeetsNETL AppB p62high confidence
Crusher#Rotaryhpinstalled0.49170.9943312.5×MeetsNETL AppB p62high confidence
Crusher#Rotaryhppurchased0.70361312.5×MeetsNETL AppB p62high confidence
Dryer#Atmospheric tray batchft2installed0.35290.999936.7×Failscapacity range 6.7×, below the 10× minimumNETL AppB p64high confidence
Dryer#Atmospheric tray batchft2purchased0.3857136.7×Failscapacity range 6.7×, below the 10× minimumNETL AppB p64high confidence
Dryer#Direct contact rotaryft2installed0.88551320×MeetsNETL AppB p64high confidence
Dryer#Direct contact rotaryft2purchased0.95391320×MeetsNETL AppB p64high confidence
Dryer#Single atmospheric drumft2installed0.57771320×MeetsNETL AppB p64high confidence
Dryer#Single atmospheric drumft2purchased0.61191320×MeetsNETL AppB p64high confidence
Evaporator#Standard horizontal tubeft2installed0.492813100×MeetsNETL AppB p61high confidence
Evaporator#Standard horizontal tubeft2purchased0.530313100×MeetsNETL AppB p61high confidence
Evaporator#Standard vertical tubeft2installed0.51510.9999360×MeetsNETL AppB p61high confidence
Evaporator#Standard vertical tubeft2purchased0.54941360×MeetsNETL AppB p61high confidence
Filter#Cartridgecfm (see note F1)installed0.28190.9539340×MeetsNETL AppB p66medium confidence
Filter#Cartridgecfm (see note F1)purchased0.49540.9419340×MeetsNETL AppB p66medium confidence
Filter#Drumft2installed0.3510.9975320×MeetsNETL AppB p66high confidence
Filter#Drumft2purchased0.39711320×MeetsNETL AppB p66high confidence
Filter#Tubular fabriccfm (see note F1)installed0.51680.9977334×MeetsNETL AppB p66medium confidence
Filter#Tubular fabriccfm (see note F1)purchased0.65241334×MeetsNETL AppB p66medium confidence
Furnace / Process Heater#CS tubes, 500 psigMMBtu/hrinstalled0.69790.9836450×Meetspromoted to processHeaterNETL AppB p60high confidence
Furnace / Process Heater#CS tubes, 500 psigMMBtu/hrpurchased0.69060.991450×Meetspromoted to processHeaterNETL AppB p60high confidence
Gas Turbine#CShpinstalled0.76050.99116370×MeetsNETL AppB p72high confidence
Gas Turbine#CShppurchased0.78330.99276370×MeetsNETL AppB p72high confidence
Horizontal Vessel#15 psig, A515 CSgallonsinstalled0.28440.980241,000×MeetsNETL AppB p53high confidence
Horizontal Vessel#15 psig, A515 CSgallonspurchased0.40830.986441,000×MeetsNETL AppB p53high confidence
Horizontal Vessel#150 psig, A515 CSgallonsinstalled0.36120.948241,000×MeetsNETL AppB p53high confidence
Horizontal Vessel#150 psig, A515 CSgallonspurchased0.55670.971341,000×MeetsNETL AppB p53high confidence
Mill#Ball millhpinstalled0.57120.9922360×MeetsNETL AppB p63high confidence
Mill#Ball millhppurchased0.76891360×MeetsNETL AppB p63high confidence
Mill#Roller millhpinstalled0.5861313.3×MeetsNETL AppB p63high confidence
Mill#Roller millhppurchased0.61131313.3×MeetsNETL AppB p63high confidence
Package Steam Boiler#A285C, 250 psiglb/hrinstalled0.42480.9747430×Meetspromoted to packageSteamBoilerNETL AppB p61high confidence
Package Steam Boiler#A285C, 250 psiglb/hrpurchased0.63180.9876430×Meetspromoted to packageSteamBoilerNETL AppB p61high confidence
Reciprocating Compressor#1 stage, 60 psia dischargeacfminstalled0.54510.9414240×Meetspromoted to recipCompressorNETL AppB p70high confidence
Reciprocating Compressor#1 stage, 60 psia dischargeacfmpurchased0.57570.94394240×Meetspromoted to recipCompressorNETL AppB p70high confidence
Reciprocating Compressor#3 stage, 440 psia dischargeacfminstalled0.53540.94733140×MeetsNETL AppB p70high confidence
Reciprocating Compressor#3 stage, 440 psia dischargeacfmpurchased0.55640.95343140×MeetsNETL AppB p70high confidence
Reciprocating Pump#Duplex, CSgpminstalled0.40820.9941340×MeetsNETL AppB p69high confidence
Reciprocating Pump#Duplex, CSgpmpurchased0.56740.9999340×MeetsNETL AppB p69high confidence
Reciprocating Pump#Triplex, CSgpminstalled0.48760.9954340×MeetsNETL AppB p69high confidence
Reciprocating Pump#Triplex, CSgpmpurchased0.62790.9999340×MeetsNETL AppB p69high confidence
Rotary Blower#CS, 1800 RPM, 8 psiggpm (as printed; see note F2)installed0.41350.9785340×MeetsNETL AppB p72medium confidence
Rotary Blower#CS, 1800 RPM, 8 psiggpm (as printed; see note F2)purchased0.54570.9947340×MeetsNETL AppB p72medium confidence
Rotary Pump#Cast irongpminstalled0.22950.904475×MeetsNETL AppB p67-68high confidence
Rotary Pump#Cast irongpmpurchased0.74730.956337.5×Failscapacity range 7.5×, below the 10× minimumNETL AppB p67-68high confidence
Shell and Tube Heat Exchanger#CS, 150 psigft2installed0.50390.89266700×FailsR² 0.8926, below the 0.90 minimumNETL AppB p58high confidence
Shell and Tube Heat Exchanger#CS, 150 psigft2purchased0.64670.92296700×MeetsNETL AppB p58high confidence
Spiral Plate Heat Exchanger#SS304, 150 psigft2installed0.52170.9757432.5×MeetsNETL AppB p59high confidence
Spiral Plate Heat Exchanger#SS304, 150 psigft2purchased0.65380.9711432.5×MeetsNETL AppB p59high confidence
Steam Turbine#over 1000 hphpinstalled0.78490.9966430×MeetsNETL AppB p73high confidence
Steam Turbine#over 1000 hphppurchased0.7565136×Failscapacity range 6×, below the 10× minimumNETL AppB p73high confidence
Steam Turbine#under 1000 hphpinstalled0.27590.9543395×MeetsNETL AppB p73high confidence
Storage Tank#Cone roof, CSgallonsinstalled0.62880.96554200×Meetspromoted to thermalStorageTankNETL AppB p54high confidence
Storage Tank#Cone roof, CSgallonspurchased0.73810.9864200×Meetspromoted to thermalStorageTankNETL AppB p54high confidence
Storage Tank#Floating roof, CSgallonsinstalled0.52670.95464200×MeetsNETL AppB p54high confidence
Storage Tank#Floating roof, CSgallonspurchased0.56440.9644200×MeetsNETL AppB p54high confidence
Vacuum Pump#1 stage, CSgpm (as printed)installed0.30230.959323.3×MeetsNETL AppB p69high confidence
Vacuum Pump#1 stage, CSgpm (as printed)purchased0.65360.9925323.3×MeetsNETL AppB p69high confidence
Vertical Vessel#15 psig, A515 CSgallonsinstalled0.26150.9948450×MeetsNETL AppB p52high confidence
Vertical Vessel#15 psig, A515 CSgallonspurchased0.30370.9999450×MeetsNETL AppB p52high confidence
Vertical Vessel#150 psig, A515 CSgallonsinstalled0.24130.9992450×MeetsNETL AppB p52high confidence
Vertical Vessel#150 psig, A515 CSgallonspurchased0.37260.9977450×MeetsNETL AppB p52high confidence

How to cite

Pemspring Energy Solutions, PEICI scaling exponent register v0.1. https://pemspring.com/cost-index/exponent-register/

To cite one fit rather than the register, use its row anchor — the # beside each equipment name is a permanent link to that row. Fit ids are stable across releases, so a citation made today still resolves after the next version is published.

Exponents are dimensionless. Capacity units are the units the data was fitted in and are not converted; costs are USD at the stated cost year. Neither varies with any display setting.

Discuss whether this fits

Tell us the problem, the site and the decision you need to reach. If this is not the right service we will say so and point you at the one that is.

United Kingdom and United States enquiries are routed to the same team. We will tell you plainly where we do and do not have local delivery capability.